Arisunime — In the unfolding drama of Silent Witch, the relationship between Casey Grove and Monica Everett (the Silent Witch) finds itself at a crossroads following a tense confrontation in which Casey is arrested for her treacherous actions. Based on details from the light novel and anime adaptation, whether Casey and Monica will ever cross paths again remains uncertain—but the potential for a dramatic reunion is palpable. While Casey’s betrayal has deeply fractured trust, narrative threads—such as lingering sympathy, shared burdens, and the interconnected fates of Serendia Academy’s students—leave open the possibility of their paths crossing anew in future volumes or episodes.
Background: Their Relationship and the Arrest
Casey Grove is introduced as a kind and carefree student at Serendia Academy, someone who often looks out for Monica, such as helping her when she was poisoned during a tea party
Silent Witch Wiki
. However, behind the facade of friendship lies deep-seated resentment—Casey blames figures like Monica (and Félix and the student council by extension) for the neglect of her impoverished homeland, where her three brothers were slain defending against dragon attacks
.
In Episode 8, it’s dramatically revealed that Casey always harbored hatred toward Monica, culminating in a plot to assassinate Prince Félix, driven by her fear that his rise to power would lead to the destruction of her territory. This betrayal marks the moment where Casey’s complex relationship with Monica unravels.
Will They Meet Again?
Current story status: As of Volume 8 of the Secrets of the Silent Witch light novel (released January 2025), a reconciliation or reunion between Casey and Monica has yet to manifest explicitly
Final Thoughts
While the initial answer remains uncertain—Casey and Monica have not (yet) met again after the arrest—the story’s evolving nature leaves the door open. Given the depth of both characters, the intricate world they inhabit, and the serialized format still unfolding, a future encounter, confrontation, or even fragile reconciliation could well emerge in the chapters ahead.
